Herbert White’s Complex Attitude- Navigating the Moral Dilemmas of ‘The Monkey’s Paw’

What is Herbert White’s attitude toward “The Monkey’s Paw”? This question has intrigued readers and critics alike since W. W. Jacobs’ short story was first published in 1902. Through the character of Herbert White, Jacobs subtly conveys a complex blend of skepticism, curiosity, and eventual dread, which ultimately contributes to the chilling atmosphere of the narrative.

Herbert White, the protagonist of the story, is introduced as a man who is initially skeptical of the supernatural. He is a pragmatic individual who relies on logic and reason to navigate the world. When he comes across the mysterious monkey’s paw, he dismisses it as a mere trinket with no power. However, his attitude begins to shift as the story progresses.

Herbert White’s skepticism is evident from the outset. When his friend, Mr. White, finds the monkey’s paw in a pawnshop and brings it home, Herbert is quick to dismiss it as a “mere curiosity.” He is not convinced that the paw possesses any magical properties, and he warns his friend to be cautious. “It’s only a trinket,” he says, “and I don’t believe in such things.” This initial skepticism sets the stage for the story’s progression and the eventual reversal of fortune.

As the story unfolds, Herbert’s curiosity begins to take hold. He is intrigued by the paw’s mysterious origins and the tales of its power that Mr. White recounts. This curiosity leads him to experiment with the paw, hoping to uncover its secrets. When he scratches the paw’s belly and the monkey’s paw responds by granting him a wish, Herbert’s attitude shifts from skepticism to one of cautious optimism.

However, as the story progresses, Herbert’s attitude becomes increasingly fraught with dread. The wish he made with the paw brings him a series of misfortunes, culminating in the tragic loss of his own life. The dread that permeates the narrative is heightened by Herbert’s realization that the paw’s power is not to be trifled with. He becomes haunted by the paw’s constant reminder of the misdeeds he has committed, and his fear of the paw’s curse grows exponentially.

In conclusion, Herbert White’s attitude toward “The Monkey’s Paw” evolves from skepticism to curiosity, and ultimately to dread. His journey through these emotions is a testament to the story’s power to unsettle and unsettle the reader. Jacobs’ portrayal of Herbert White serves as a cautionary tale about the dangers of indulging in curiosity and the perils of seeking supernatural power. The story’s chilling conclusion leaves readers questioning the true nature of the monkey’s paw and the consequences of seeking to control the unexplainable.